Search User Login Menu
Tools
Close
Close

Ontario News

News/Ontario
News from Across Northern Ontario, Ontario, Lake Superior News From Kenora, Rainy River, Thunder Bay, Marathon, Terrace Bay, White River, Greenstone, Sault Ste Marie, Sudbury, and North Bay, Ontario

Latest Ontario News

Trudeau shouldn’t be raising payroll taxes
Troy Media
/ Categories: Ontario, Economy

Trudeau shouldn’t be raising payroll taxes

bill for each middle-class worker increased by $818 this year alone

THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO  ~~~~~~   September 3, 2022 (LSNews)  Political pundits are twisting themselves into pretzels arguing mandatory Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance payments are not a tax.

They’re missing the point: the government is taking too much money from Canadians.

If you make $65,000 this year, then the federal government is taking nearly $4,500 directly from your pay through CPP and EI taxes. Every employer must also cough up an extra $4,800. That’s more than $9,200 that a working mom could’ve used to buy formula, ground beef or pay for dental bills, but instead, she and her employer have to fork it over to the feds.

Franco TerrazzanoThe total payroll tax bill for each middle-class worker increased by $818 this year. In fact, payroll taxes have increased three times since the beginning of the pandemic.

And over the decade, the total annual payroll tax paid for each middle-class worker has increased by $2,435. The annual CPP tax alone increased by nearly 50 per cent. Can workers expect to retire 50 per cent earlier? Did seniors’ pension cheques increase by 50 per cent? Don’t count on it.

There’s no debate that the government is taking more money from workers through higher CPP and EI payments.

But should CPP and EI payments be considered taxes?

Yes.

If something looks like a duck, waddles like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it’s a duck. Likewise, if it takes money from you like a tax, funds government spending like a tax, and even the government admits it’s a tax, then it’s a tax.

Unlike fees, payroll taxes are mandatory. You can choose whether you want to purchase insurance from Manulife, a sandwich from Subway or a ticket from Via Rail. The taxman doesn’t give you a choice when it comes to your CPP and EI payments.

Payroll taxes also don’t directly pay for your service. You pay $160 at a government passport office to renew your passport. That’s a fee. But that’s not what happens with CPP payments.

“There’s an assumption that the money one pays into the CPP is going to fund their own personal retirement,” explained Charles Lammam and Hugh MacIntyre of the Fraser Institute. “[But] most of the contributions you make today fund someone else’s retirement.”

The money that comes off your pay cheque largely funds today’s retirees.

When you retire, you won’t be spending your money. Your cheques will be coming from future generations. And you’ll be counting on future politicians to keep the fund healthy and deliver those cheques.

But there is no legal requirement for a future government to provide pension benefits. And if you pass away early, your CPP benefits aren’t fully transferred to your family.

That means you don’t truly own the money you’re forced to pay into the CPP.

Let’s review. The government forces you to pay for CPP and EI. The government then redistributes much of that money to other people. That’s the definition of a tax.

Even the federal government admits CPP and EI payments are taxes.

If you type “what taxes you pay” into Google, the first result is a government website that lists the various taxes Canadians pay. Just below income taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, and tariffs are CPP and EI payroll taxes. The Tax Court of Canada deals with appeals to EI or CPP decisions. As a member of Parliament, Justin Trudeau described rising EI payments as “a direct payroll tax increase.”

It’s a good bet most Canadians aren’t too concerned whether deductions from their paystubs are described as a contribution, levy, fee or tax. Canadians are concerned that their pay isn’t keeping up with the rising cost of living. Politicians should focus on the real concern and stop eating away at Canadians’ pay with higher payroll taxes.

Franco Terrazzano is the Federal Director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.

#LSN_Econ  #LSN_TBay  #LSN_NorWest 

Below Please Rate and Share this story 
To help us learn what is important to you
 

© Troy Media

Disclaimer
The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by Lake Superior News / Lake Superior Media.

Troy Media Founded in 2005, Troy Media has grown to become Canada’s largest independent provider of original editorial features, opinions and analysis. Content sourced from Troy Media appears in dozens of newspapers, news sites, blogs and radio reports daily. Annual readership is estimated to be greater than 750 million.

 

Previous Article Ontario Strengthening Cyber Security and Protecting Ontarians Online
Next Article Ontario Trillium Foundation grant $49,600 to supports Vox Popular
Print
Rate this article:
5.0
2Upvote 2Downvote

Our Tweeter Feeds for Thunder Bay and Sault Ste Marie

norm.gale@thunderbay.ca,
bill.mauro@thunderbay.ca,
brian.hamilton@thunderbay.ca,
mark.bentz@thunderbay.ca,
trevor.giertuga@thunderbay.ca,
brian.mckinnon@thunderbay.ca,
aldo.ruberto@thunderbay.ca,
cody.fraser@thunderbay.ca,
rebecca.johnson@thunderbay.ca
andrew.foulds@thunderbay.ca,
krshelby.chng@thunderbay.ca
Bill Mauro 625 3600
Alberto Aiello 629 7531
Mark Bentz 628 6910

Bill Mauro 625 3600
Alberto Aiello 629 7531Mark Bentz 628 6910
Shelby Ch’ng 708 1983
Andrew Foulds – no number
Cody Fraser 633 3846
Trevor Giertuga 683 8041 628 4790
B Hamilton 251 2551
R Johnson 577 2807Brian McKinnon 767 2807
K Oliver 627 2036
Aldo Ruberto 628 5547
Peng You 768 0827 628 4305
Kisten.oliver@thunderbay.ca,

 

 

 

Follow LSN on Twitter

South Shore

«December 2022»
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
27
  • Medal of Merit nominations Open
    Medal of Merit nominations  Open

    Medal of Merit nominations Open

    SAULT STE MARIE, ONTARIO ~~~~~  November 1, 2022 (LSNews) The City of Sault Ste. Marie invites nominations for the 2022 Medal of Merit Award.  

    The Medal of Merit is awarded to individuals or groups who have achieved exceptional meritorious honours in athletics, cultural or academic fields or who make extraordinary contributions to the community.  

    #LSN_SSM  

     

    Read more
2829
  • Medal of Merit nominations Open
    Medal of Merit nominations  Open

    Medal of Merit nominations Open

    SAULT STE MARIE, ONTARIO ~~~~~  November 1, 2022 (LSNews) The City of Sault Ste. Marie invites nominations for the 2022 Medal of Merit Award.  

    The Medal of Merit is awarded to individuals or groups who have achieved exceptional meritorious honours in athletics, cultural or academic fields or who make extraordinary contributions to the community.  

    #LSN_SSM  

     

    Read more
30
  • Medal of Merit nominations Open
    Medal of Merit nominations  Open

    Medal of Merit nominations Open

    SAULT STE MARIE, ONTARIO ~~~~~  November 1, 2022 (LSNews) The City of Sault Ste. Marie invites nominations for the 2022 Medal of Merit Award.  

    The Medal of Merit is awarded to individuals or groups who have achieved exceptional meritorious honours in athletics, cultural or academic fields or who make extraordinary contributions to the community.  

    #LSN_SSM  

     

    Read more
123
45678910
  • Christmas Light Parade
    Christmas Light Parade

    Christmas Light Parade

    THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO ~~~~~  December 1, 2022 (LSNews)  The parade route starts at Manitoulin Transport on Main St. and comes over the bridge at Intercity to Memorial Ave. Coming North up Memorial Ave to Queen St where in front of the Whole Sale Club and down Fort William Rd will be the Sensory section with no honking or music playing.

    Bring your spare change to drop in the buckets of the volunteers to be shared among George Jeffery Children's Centre, Autism Thunder Bay, Special Olympics, and Theraputic Riding.

    #LSN_PublicSafety #LSN_TBPS #LSN_TBay  #LSN_CircleTour

    Read more
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
1234567

Latest News

Back To Top