Search User Login Menu
Tools
Close
Close

Ontario News

News/Ontario
News from Across Northern Ontario, Ontario, Lake Superior News From Kenora, Rainy River, Thunder Bay, Marathon, Terrace Bay, White River, Greenstone, Sault Ste Marie, Sudbury, and North Bay, Ontario

Latest Ontario News

Here's what school choice in Ontario could look like for parents
Fraser Institute

Here's what school choice in Ontario could look like for parents

school choice—letting parents take their tax dollars to schools they choose for their children and making alternative schools more affordable

THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO ~~~~~   November 20, 2022  (LSNews)    In Ontario, school choice—letting parents take their tax dollars to schools they choose for their children and making alternative schools more affordable to all families—is long overdue. The CUPE strike was just the latest example of Ontario children being held hostage by the gatekeepers of the government-run public school system. It’s time for the government to stop exclusively funding the current one-size-fits-all system and start funding students instead.

Why? Because many lower- and middle-class Ontario families don’t have a choice. They can choose their grocery stores, their daycares and preschools. Yet unlike parents in half the provinces, they cannot afford to choose their kids’ schools.

 The Ford government could change that.

First, it could make it easier for families to switch to any government public school they choose, without adhering to catchment areas as other provinces such as British Columbia have done.

The government could also send a portion of parents’ tax dollars to schools of their choice. In Quebec, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and B.C. the provincial government does exactly that by funding independent schools from 35 per cent to 80 per cent of the per-student cost of government public schools. This helps increase school choice and also saves taxpayer money. Every child who attends an independent school costs taxpayers less than students who attend government public schools.

Like in Alberta, Ontario could also allow charter schools, which are common in Sweden, the United States and elsewhere. Typically, governments fund charter schools, parents pay no tuition, and parents and teachers run the schools, which often have their own unique educational offering. Alberta’s non-profit charter schools include a STEM school, an English Second Language school, a music school and an Indigenous culture school.

Finally, Ontario could introduce education savings accounts for every family, which could be spent on independent schooling, homeschooling, tutoring or other educational activities like in Arizona, Singapore and elsewhere. In Australia, a voucher system funds student attendance at independent schools, with a higher value for low-income families, based on area of residence. Ontario could even revisit its old income-tested partial tax credit for families, introduced and then squelched in the early 2000s.

The question of demand has been answered. Even in Ontario’s current system where the government offers no independent school funding, enrolment in independent schools is increasing. From 2006-07 to 2019-20, the share of Ontario kids enrolled in independent schools jumped from 5.1 per cent to 6.9 per cent. Over the same period, the share of students opting to homeschool also increased while the share of kids enrolled in government-run public schools decreased.

Of course, some critics posit that allowing parents to affordably choose their kids’ schools would gut government public schools. But if public schools are providing a high-quality education for kids, why would that be the case?

Other critics say school choice is for the wealthy, an illogical claim given the wealthy already have school choice because they can afford to pay twice—their tax bill, which funds the government public school system, and again for tuition at an independent school. And in Alberta, research has found that families with children in most independent schools actually have slightly lower incomes than families with children in government-run public schools. School choice simply gives lower- and middle-class families greater opportunity to choose their kids’ schools.

Whether Ontario parents want a unique pedagogy, are concerned about the province’s tumbling math scores, or want to bypass the anxiety of school closures and labour strife, they should be allowed to use their own tax dollars to choose their kids’ schools regardless of their income or postal code.

Author:

Paige MacPherson

Associate Director, Education Policy

#LSN_ONNews  #LSN_TBay  #LSN_SSM  #LSN_NorWest 

Below Please Rate and Share this story 
To help us learn what is important to you
 

    The Fraser Institute is an independent, non-partisan research and educational organization based in Canada. We have offices in Calgary, Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver. Visit our Website 

Previous Article Education Workers Strike Averted
Next Article What Will You Give Up When Governments Declare the Next Emergency?
Print
Rate this article:
5.0
1Upvote 0Downvote

Our Tweeter Feeds for Thunder Bay and Sault Ste Marie

norm.gale@thunderbay.ca,
bill.mauro@thunderbay.ca,
brian.hamilton@thunderbay.ca,
mark.bentz@thunderbay.ca,
trevor.giertuga@thunderbay.ca,
brian.mckinnon@thunderbay.ca,
aldo.ruberto@thunderbay.ca,
cody.fraser@thunderbay.ca,
rebecca.johnson@thunderbay.ca
andrew.foulds@thunderbay.ca,
krshelby.chng@thunderbay.ca
Bill Mauro 625 3600
Alberto Aiello 629 7531
Mark Bentz 628 6910

Bill Mauro 625 3600
Alberto Aiello 629 7531Mark Bentz 628 6910
Shelby Ch’ng 708 1983
Andrew Foulds – no number
Cody Fraser 633 3846
Trevor Giertuga 683 8041 628 4790
B Hamilton 251 2551
R Johnson 577 2807Brian McKinnon 767 2807
K Oliver 627 2036
Aldo Ruberto 628 5547
Peng You 768 0827 628 4305
Kisten.oliver@thunderbay.ca,

 

 

 

Follow LSN on Twitter

South Shore

«December 2022»
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
27
  • Medal of Merit nominations Open
    Medal of Merit nominations  Open

    Medal of Merit nominations Open

    SAULT STE MARIE, ONTARIO ~~~~~  November 1, 2022 (LSNews) The City of Sault Ste. Marie invites nominations for the 2022 Medal of Merit Award.  

    The Medal of Merit is awarded to individuals or groups who have achieved exceptional meritorious honours in athletics, cultural or academic fields or who make extraordinary contributions to the community.  

    #LSN_SSM  

     

    Read more
2829
  • Medal of Merit nominations Open
    Medal of Merit nominations  Open

    Medal of Merit nominations Open

    SAULT STE MARIE, ONTARIO ~~~~~  November 1, 2022 (LSNews) The City of Sault Ste. Marie invites nominations for the 2022 Medal of Merit Award.  

    The Medal of Merit is awarded to individuals or groups who have achieved exceptional meritorious honours in athletics, cultural or academic fields or who make extraordinary contributions to the community.  

    #LSN_SSM  

     

    Read more
30
  • Medal of Merit nominations Open
    Medal of Merit nominations  Open

    Medal of Merit nominations Open

    SAULT STE MARIE, ONTARIO ~~~~~  November 1, 2022 (LSNews) The City of Sault Ste. Marie invites nominations for the 2022 Medal of Merit Award.  

    The Medal of Merit is awarded to individuals or groups who have achieved exceptional meritorious honours in athletics, cultural or academic fields or who make extraordinary contributions to the community.  

    #LSN_SSM  

     

    Read more
123
45678910
  • Christmas Light Parade
    Christmas Light Parade

    Christmas Light Parade

    THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO ~~~~~  December 1, 2022 (LSNews)  The parade route starts at Manitoulin Transport on Main St. and comes over the bridge at Intercity to Memorial Ave. Coming North up Memorial Ave to Queen St where in front of the Whole Sale Club and down Fort William Rd will be the Sensory section with no honking or music playing.

    Bring your spare change to drop in the buckets of the volunteers to be shared among George Jeffery Children's Centre, Autism Thunder Bay, Special Olympics, and Theraputic Riding.

    #LSN_PublicSafety #LSN_TBPS #LSN_TBay  #LSN_CircleTour

    Read more
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
1234567

Latest News

Back To Top